Spatial
Analysis
Based on the
Walter Christaller’s central place theory, suggested locations for the
new MEC
retail store must be located within its sphere of influence so that it
can
provide services to the inhabitants.
Two basic
principles of central place theory must be noticed: the range and the
threshold
of goods and services.
The range of a
good or service is the maximum distance that people are prepared to
ravel to
obtain it. According to his assumptions, some central places offer only
convenience or low-order goods, which are brought frequently and daily,
are not
sufficiently high in value to attract customers from further than the
immediate
catchment area and so have a small sphere of influence. For example
people are
not prepared to travel far to buy a newspaper. Other central places
offer
comparison or higher-order goods, which are purchased less frequently
but which
need a much higher threshold population. People are willing to travel
further
to get what they want and so these central places have much larger
spheres of
influence. For example people are more prepared to travel considerable
distances to high-order outdoor equipment at MEC.
The threshold of
a good or service is the minimum number of people required to support
it.
Services locate where they can maximize the number of people in their
catchment
area and maximize the distance form the nearest rival. It is assumed
that people will always use the service located nearest to them. As a
rule, the more specialised the service, the greatest the number of
people needed to make it profitable or viable. According to this rule,
the new MEC store must be located in a region that contain enough
people to make it profitable.
Therefore, Six regional municipality
boundaries
(RMB) are selected as their
populations are over 118801 which are potential for suggested locations
for a new MEC shown in Map 1:
- CAPITAL
REGIONAL DISTRICT
- CENTRAL
OKANAGAN REGIONAL DISTRICT
- FRASER VALLEY
REGIONAL DISTRICT
- GREATER
VANCOUVER REGIONAL
DISTRICT
- NANAIMO
REGIONAL DISTRICT
- THOMPSON-NICOLA
REGIONAL
DISTRICT
Top 12
Tographic Coverage Areas (TCA) are also chosen that are
intersected by RMB:
PID
|
Full-Name
|
Map 1:
Major Topographic Coverage Areas
within Regional
Municipality Boundaries |
0
|
ABBOTSFORD
|
|
19
|
CHILLIWACK
|
33
|
DUNCAN
|
56
|
KAMLOOPS
|
58
|
KELOWNA
|
74
|
MERRITT
|
81
|
NANAIMO |
90
|
PARKSVILLE
|
130
|
SUMMERLAND
|
142
|
VANCOUVER
|
143
|
VERNON
|
144
|
VICTORIA
|
The preferred
locations for the new MEC retail store must be located outside the
Greater Vancouver Region District as the
existing MEC retail store has
successfully covered the range and the threshold of central place
functions in
the this region. Thus, people who live in the lower
mainland will probably visit the existing MEC store located at the 130
West Broadway (49°11' N, 123°10' W).
The suggested
locations for the new MEC store, which
is a
high-order good, needs a large threshold population and therefore have
to
attract people from the whole region or beyond. Therefore, the
suggested
locations are determined by the frequency of visit, their
accessibility, the
cost of land and population.
On map 2, 120
kilometers buffer distance for the exisitng MEC is assigned to show its
serving
boundary. According to this buffer zone, any potential
tographic coverage areas within the zone will be ignored and the rest
of those potential tographic coverage areas are suitable for the new
MEC retail store. Kamloop, Kelowna, Merritt,
Summerland and Vernon are counted as potential regions for a new MEC
store.
Map 2:
The Existing MEC Store and its
Serving Boundary
|
MEC products are higher quality, which are
higher-order goods, than other outdoor brands so that MEC has larger
spheres of
influence in order to cover the Okanagan
Valley population. Therefore Okanagan
Valley
is the potential region for a new MEC store because it covers a vast area of BC’s interior
including
cities.
Kelowna region
will be chosen for the new MEC store not because it has the highest
population in the Okanagan valley, but it is situated
on the
eastern shore of Okanagan Lake mid-way between Penticton in the south
and Vernon in the north that is the main transportation point for surrounding areas such
as Merritt,
Kamloops,
Vernon,
and Summerland.
In addition, the city of Kelowna
is selected because it is located in the center of the Central
Okanagan Region District that
contains a large threshold population and it has developed a better housing estates,
neighbourhood units and central business district (CBD) that other
region districts in the Okanagan Valley so as to be within easy
reach of their customers.
Map 3: Location of Kelowna |
|
Map 4 shows the existing outdoor
retail stores in kelowna and different
land use categories. In my analysis, the suggested locations for the
new MEC store must not be located in the commercial park and
recreational, resource and industrial, and government and institutional
land use. Thus the new MEC
store will be located
in these land use
areas: Residential and Open Area.
Map 4: Land Use Category and the
Locations of Existing Outdoor Retails
|
|
Potential land use areas
are the areas contain residential and
open area. Commercial areas are not selected for potential locations
as the land prices will be realtively higher than those in the open
areas and residential areas. Map 5 provides a clear spatial pattern of
potential land use areas for the new MEC store.
Map 5: Potential Land Use Area
for the New MEC Retail Store
|
|
In order to
refine the potential area from map 5, a query is performed to narrow
down the the potential area.
First, the suggested locations must not
be
located near the Railway as it will destroy the amenity.
Therefore, polygons within 100 meters distance of Railway will be
counted as non-potential areas on Map 6. On
the other hand, the new MEC
store must be within 100 metres of major roads and highways, which are
Cadder Drive, Cardon Ave, Havery Ave, Highways 33, Highway 97, Pandosy
Street, Rutland Road, Spall Road and Springfield Road based on the map
6. It is crucial to select a location that is
visible from major roads
and highways because many MEC members are from outlying areas that they
will take this major roads and highways. Map 7 shows those potential
areas which are within 100 meters distance of major roads and highways.
Map 6:
Non-Potential Site
within 100 Meters Distance of Major BC railway
|
Map 7: Potential
Areas
within
100 Meters Distance of Major Roads and Highways
|
|
|
After multi-queries
are performed to find out the potential site from
the landuse and major roads and highways, the next step is to
intersect potential site and high average household income. However,
before I intersect these two layers, a query for high average houldhold
income is needed. Map 8 indicates the average household pattern in
Kelowna. The result of this layer is generated from the DA layer
associated with the census table.
Map 8: High Average
Household
Income
|
|
Another query is performed in map 9. Specifics with regards
to actual income levels of individuals have served as a better tool. In
focusing on this aspect, the
degree of employment can be easily inferred simply by observing
income
figures. This will also provide
better estimates into levels expendable income that will be used
towards
products at MEC.
However, in this layer,
only the
top two average household
income groups with high population density areas are selected. It is
because I want to avoid any modifiable areal unit problems and
ecological fallacy in my analysis that I will discuss in Operational
Problems. On Map 10, a query is performed
to intersect average
household income and potential areas. The result of this layer
indicates the spatial distribution of the most potential
customers that can support the operation of the new MEC retail store.
Map 9: Top Two Average Household Income
with High Population Density
|
Map 10: Potential Areas with High average income and Population Density |
|
|
This
query will
be
the 1000 meters buffer zone of competition. Ideal Locations for
New MEC retail Store will be formed by removing any areas within the
1000 meters buffer zone of competition. Moreover, based on the idea of
catchment concept, the new
MEC retail store's buffer zone (catchment area) cannot not be
overlapped
with those competitors' buffer zones. Therefore, I will remove
any ideal locations fall in another 1000 meters buffer distance of the
current competitor's buffer zone.
Map 11: Ideal Locations outside
Competition's buffer zones |
|
RESULTS
AND DISSCUSSIONS
The creation of a new
Mountain Equipment Co-op store in Kelowna,
BC
proves to
be a plausible project that will likely be very successful. Once
analysis and all of the
various processes are completed and involved, as previously discussed,
I end up with
the
resulting map 12. This shows Three Suggested Locations for the NEW
Mountain Equipment Co-op that can be viewed from the main highway
in Kelowna.
Map 12: Suggested Locations for
the New Mountain Equipment
Co-op Retail Store
|
|
There are many steps
involved in achieving the final product, but the transition between
maps 11
to 12 have
three main steps. I need to decide on a location for the new MEC store
from the 8
remaining “ideal” locations. These ideal
locations that are within 100 meters
of
major roads and highways, are outside of the 1000 meters buffer
distance of competitors, and are in areas with high average household
income and high population density in the labour force. I think
that the first set of criteria, that
is, being within 100 meters of major highways, is probably the
most important. This is for reasons such
as many people
simply passing through Kelowna
This location will be especially crucial in
the summer as Kelowna’s
population virtually doubles in size with the masses of tourists,
either making the city their destination for holiday, or others who are
just
passing through. Also, locating within 100 meters of major roads caters
to the local population, who do their day-to-day
shopping for items such as groceries in the same area. In
addition, many Okanagan residents make the
commute to Kelowna,
either on a daily basis for work, or occasionally for shopping.
Secondly, locating the
MEC store at least 1000 meters away from competitors and commercial
areas will
ensure the
interests of both new and current customers of outdoor gear will be
met. For instance, many customers who normally shop at a nearby
competitor, may choose the new MEC because of
its
location being closer to their places of dwelling.
The location will also spark the interests
of new customers who live in close proximity simply out of curiosity of
the new
store in their neighborhood and special promotions for those within a
certain
postal code range.
Finally, a location for
the MEC in an area with a high level of individuals in the labour force
will
aid in its success. For example, a high
population density for a set area, in which people are working,
indicates that
there are a greater number of people with expendable income. Subsequently, these people may be drawn to
the new store and its goods and be able to afford products on a regular
basis. Because MEC products are higher
quality than
many other outdoors brands, prices may be slightly higher than many
people are
accustomed to, although due to its large scale they remain relatively
competitive. This fact results in fewer
unemployed people who are unable to afford gear on a consistent basis,
which
supports the above criteria for locating within a high populated area
who are
in the labour force.
___________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Site
Design by Benjamin Lee, Department of Geography
Simon Fraser University
8888 University Drive
Burnaby, B.C.
Canada. V5A 1S6